๐ŸŽ Holiday Curl Giveaway: 5 winners get curly hair products hand-picked for their hair. Enter by Dec 20.

Troubleshooting: How to Tell If a Curl Product Is Wrong for You

Before you toss that curl product and hop to the next one, make sure the product is actually the problem.

This is the troubleshooting framework I use with my Curl Coaching clients so they stop wasting money on the wrong products. Itโ€™s part of my Troubleshooting Series, where I teach you how to solve your own curl problems, so when your hair changes, you know what to do next.

Here is the framework at a glance.

Weโ€™ll start with what to judge a product on, then run three of the most common product complaints through the process.

Step 1: Observe

What Are You Unhappy With?

โ€œThis product didnโ€™t work for meโ€ isnโ€™t enough detail to troubleshoot. Name the actual problem first.

Are you unhappy with how your hair looks? Check these:

  • Frizz
  • Volume
  • Clump size
  • Curl bounce
  • Shine

Or are you unhappy with how it feels? It could be:

  • Too soft or mushy
  • Rough or brittle
  • Too much texture or grit

What Is That Productโ€™s Job?

Every product category has a job, and that job is what you judge it on. Here is each one:

  • Shampoo cleans your hair.
  • Conditioner softens and gives you slip. It wonโ€™t tame frizz or define your curls, even when itโ€™s marketed for curls.
  • Prep products do the same job as conditioner, but you leave them in. These are leave-in conditioners, heat protectants, and some curl creams that go under your main styler.
  • Stylers improve how your hair looks. These are gels, mousses, hairsprays, and some curl creams.

Is That Something the Product Is Supposed to Do?

Compare what youโ€™re unhappy with to the productโ€™s job. Youโ€™ll land in one of three places.

Itโ€™s not the productโ€™s job. Then the product didnโ€™t fail.

  • People compliment my curls and ask what products I use. What theyโ€™re seeing mostly comes down to my styling technique.
  • Volume works the same way. It comes mostly from technique, like diffusing with the prongs and lifting your hair off your scalp as you style.
  • Stylers do help some. A texturized feel gives your hair grip so it doesnโ€™t lie too flat, and you need both for the most volume.

The product does its job, but you donโ€™t like how your hair feels. Thatโ€™s a trade-off.

  • If a product gives you the volume you wanted, you might have to accept a little of that texturized feel.
  • You still have levers, like how much of the texturizing product you use and how you layer it with products that soften. I cover this in How To Balance Texture and Softness.
  • If your hair feels brittle, rough, or tangled, check whether your products give you enough conditioning. You could add a leave-in conditioner under your styler.

It is the productโ€™s job, and itโ€™s not doing it. Now you find out whether you need to switch products. Keep going.

Step 2: Identify When

Next, pin down when you noticed the problem. Other variables come in throughout your routine, so judge each product at the moment its job shows up.

  • Shampoo: right after you rinse. Your hair should feel very clean. Wanting to reach for conditioner is a good sign that youโ€™re starting with a clean base.
  • Conditioner: while itโ€™s in your hair. If you canโ€™t get your hands through your hair even with a lot of it, itโ€™s not conditioning enough. If your hair feels coated, waxy, or mushy even after a long rinse, itโ€™s too heavy.
  • Prep: once your hair is dry and after you break the cast. If you arenโ€™t getting hold, it may be too rich in conditioning. If it felt like nothing was there and you couldnโ€™t detangle, it may not be conditioning enough.
  • Styler: once your hair is dry and after you break the cast. This is when you can see how your hair looks and whether it holds. If the problem shows up later in the day or the next morning, note that too.

Step 3: Rule Out

Ask yourself these questions to rule out other variables before you switch products.

Example 1: โ€œMy Styler Doesnโ€™t Give Me Enough Holdโ€

This goes for any styler you use for hold, like a gel or mousse.

Once Dry: Did You Get a Cast?

A cast is the crunchy feel your hair dries down with after styling. You should get one if you want your curls to hold and last longer.

  • No cast at all? You probably didnโ€™t use enough. This is the most common culprit I see.
  • A patchy cast with patchy frizz? You probably didnโ€™t get even coverage.

Both are application fixes, not necessarily a product problem. My Rake, Lift, Define Method walks you through application.

No Cast or a Patchy Cast: Is Your Water Right for This Gel?

Water dilutes your styler, and the more diluted it is, the less hold you get. Balancing the water in your hair with the amount of product is tricky, and it takes experimenting.

Here is how Iโ€™d adjust the water for three gels.

Tootilab Extreme Weather Styling Water Gel

  • Hold: Strong
  • Texture: None
  • Slip: High
  • Conditioning: Low
  • Protein: None
  • Heat Protection: Yes
  • UV Protection: No
  • Unique Benefits: Comes in fragrance-free; humectants moisturize without weight; humidity-blocking ingredients

This gel is watery, with a serum-like texture, so you donโ€™t need as much water.

  • If you style soaking wet, in the shower, or with the bowl method, you probably wonโ€™t get a cast because youโ€™re diluting it too much.
  • You have to use a lot of it to get strong hold.
  • If you microplop (scrunch with your hair towel after styling), go back in with a second light glaze of gel. That glaze goes on hair that isnโ€™t as wet, so itโ€™s less diluted and gives you extra hold.

Curlsmith Fragrance-Free Strong Hold Gel

  • Hold: Strong
  • Texture: Medium-High
  • Slip: Low
  • Conditioning: Low
  • Protein: None
  • Heat Protection: No
  • UV Protection: No
  • Unique Benefits: Fragrance-free; humidity protection

This gel is thick, so use more water to spread it evenly. Emulsify it with water in your palms to thin it out, or it will stick to one area.

  • The most common complaint I hear is a patchy cast or not enough hold. That usually means you need to use more and spread it evenly.
  • Itโ€™s texturizing, so itโ€™s one to try if you struggle with volume.

Bounce Curl Chia Seed Clumping Gel

  • Hold: Medium-Strong
  • Texture: Medium
  • Slip: Medium
  • Conditioning: Low-Medium
  • Protein: None
  • Heat Protection: No
  • UV Protection: No
  • Unique Benefits: Humidity-blocking ingredients; buildable hold and texture; encourages clumping

This gel gives a medium but buildable hold. Itโ€™s thicker than the Tootilab gel but not as thick as the Curlsmith, so it needs more water to spread.

  • If your cast is hard to break, you probably used more than you need, so dial it back.
  • It can be more forgiving. Use a lot and youโ€™ll likely get a cast even when your water isnโ€™t quite right.

Still No Cast: Whatโ€™s Under Your Gel?

If you used enough, applied it evenly, and didnโ€™t dilute it too much, look at what you put on underneath.

A very softening prep softens the hold of your gel, because the gel canโ€™t grip your hair as well. That includes a leave-in, a curl cream, or even your heat protectant. Using too much of it does the same thing.

If thatโ€™s not it and you still canโ€™t get a cast, that styler may not be right for you.

After Breaking the Cast: Did Your Curls Frizz or Fall?

A cast tells you your application was right. What happens when you break it tells you about the gel.

  • Did your curls fall limp? Your gel may be too conditioning for you, especially if youโ€™ve already ruled out too much conditioning underneath.
  • Did your hair frizz up? This is what I see most often, and itโ€™s usually the product. I see it a lot with very natural gels. They donโ€™t have longevity, and I donโ€™t consider that hold, so itโ€™s time to switch gels.

Example 2: โ€œMy Curls Donโ€™t Last Through the Day or to Day Twoโ€

Your hair looked great once it dried, and your curls held when you broke the cast. Then they didnโ€™t last.

Frizz and curls loosening are both forms of not lasting, but theyโ€™re different things. They can show up together or on their own, so notice which one you have. I hear this most with waves and loose curls.

During the Day: What Happened After You Broke the Cast?

Look at everything between breaking your cast and the end of the day.

  • Was your hair fully dry before you went out?
  • Was it humid? A product can only do so much in high humidity.
  • Did you have a sweaty workout?
  • Did you pull it up into a tight bun and take it down?
  • Did you touch it a lot? I do this without realizing it.

If one of these ruined your curls, it isnโ€™t fair to say the gel didnโ€™t give you hold.

By the Next Morning: Is It Your Sleep Protection?

If you woke up with frizz or looser curls, look at your sleep protection first. Itโ€™s the main thing that happened overnight.

  • If the same thing happens overnight no matter which product you use, your sleep protection method needs adjusting. How you put it on matters too.
  • Change that one variable. If the problem goes away, it wasnโ€™t the product.

I go deeper on this in Why Your Curls Donโ€™t Last Past Wash Day.

Still Not Lasting: Is Your Gel Too Conditioning?

If your curls loosen through the day and lose their shape, ask whether your gel is too conditioning for your hair. Not enough texture or grit can do the same thing.

Here is a gel I often hear this about.

Ouidad Advanced Climate Control Heat & Humidity Stronger Hold Gel

  • Hold: Medium-Strong
  • Texture: None
  • Slip: High
  • Conditioning: High
  • Protein: High
  • Heat Protection: No
  • UV Protection: Yes
  • Unique Benefits: Humidity protection

This gel has a lot of conditioning in it. If your hair is already very soft and falls easily, itโ€™s not the gel Iโ€™d recommend for you. My curls generally hold their shape through the day, so I get long-lasting hold with it.

If you like how a gel makes your hair feel and want it to last longer, try these before you buy something new:

  • Add a hairspray on top. Start with one you already have and see what the two do together.
  • Cut out the leave-in and curl cream underneath, and use the gel by itself.

If your curls still fall, thereโ€™s too much conditioning at this step.

This is the hairspray I use as an example.

AG Ultradynamics Extra-Firm Finishing Spray

  • Hold: Medium
  • Texture: Medium
  • Conditioning: None
  • Protein: None
  • Heat Protection: No
  • UV Protection: No
  • Unique Benefits: Humidity resistant; helps counteract overly soft hair

It still has a flexible feel, depending on how much you use. It adds a little texture so your hair doesnโ€™t feel too soft.

Day Two: Is Your Gel Giving You Long-Lasting Hold?

Sometimes a gel gives you hold, but not enough long-lasting hold for what you need. If youโ€™re refreshing more than you want to, even with the right application, thatโ€™s a fair reason to move on.

I compare my day two results between gels. If day two looks the same or better, great. If it looks worse, that gel didnโ€™t have enough hold for me.

If itโ€™s time for a new gel, my How to Pick Gels Cheat Sheet shows you what to look for.

Example 3: โ€œIs My Shampoo Strong Enough?โ€

If your application is right, your gel is right for you, and your curls still arenโ€™t lasting, work backward to your wash.

Right After You Rinse: Did Your Hair and Scalp Get Clean?

These are signs your shampoo didnโ€™t get your scalp clean:

  • Your hair feels tacky or oily.
  • Water still beads up on your scalp.
  • You see residue under your nails when you gently scratch your scalp.

That means scalp oils and product residue are still there.

After Shampooing Twice: Is It Still Not Clean?

Rule out your application first.

  • Shampoo twice, which helps you get even coverage.
  • Scrub with the pads of your fingers, massage it into your scalp, and cover all areas.

If you shampooed thoroughly and twice and you still feel it, that shampoo isnโ€™t strong enough.

You can also check the label. A lot of butters and oils at the top of the ingredients list means the shampoo leaves them behind on your hair. You probably need something stronger with fewer conditioning ingredients.

Over Several Wash Days: Is Buildup Adding Up?

If the buildup you feel is accumulating over wash days, it may be time to clarify. If you donโ€™t have a clarifying shampoo in your wash day rotation, get one.

My Best Shampoos and Conditioners post has my picks and what to look for.

Step 4: Test Whatโ€™s Left

Test fairly, which means changing one variable at a time. I know thatโ€™s hard, because we get impatient.

  • Change one thing. Keep everything else the same.
  • Give it more than one wash day. I donโ€™t test a product just once, because I need to test it different ways.
  • Note the weather. It affects your results.
  • Document it. Write down what you did and what you changed, because itโ€™s hard to remember.

When I first tried the Tootilab gel, I used it by itself with nothing underneath, plus my usual shampoo and conditioner. I wanted to see how much hold I could get without other variables at play.

For documenting, I created my Curly Hair Tracker & Planner. Itโ€™s an in-depth spreadsheet where you can list what you did, add photos, and track the weather. Photos with a few notes on your phone work too.

My Curl Experiments Series follows this same testing process. In the last one, I used way too much water on one side and not enough on the other. View the difference here.

Step 5: Read the Result

Look at what changed after your test.

  • Better? Keep it.
  • Worse? Undo it.
  • No change? Rule it out. No change is information too.

What You Canโ€™t Control Sets Your Range

Everything so far is within your control. I call these levers with my clients. If youโ€™ve done all of it and still arenโ€™t getting the results you want, factor in what you canโ€™t control.

  • Density. I see this with volume. You can maximize your volume potential, but you canโ€™t change the number of hairs on your head.
  • Curl pattern. Testing makes sure you reach your full curl potential, but that may be as curly as your hair gets.
  • Scalp type. You canโ€™t always control oil.
  • Weather. You canโ€™t control it, so you work with it.
  • Lifestyle. If a workout is why your curls didnโ€™t last, thatโ€™s okay. You refresh.

None of these are failures. They set your range.

There is a natural ceiling for everything, but most people havenโ€™t tested properly to find it. They changed four things at once, got impatient, or werenโ€™t used to recognizing the signs.

When It Really Is the Product, Pick a Better Gel

Before you replace a product, diagnose it.

If youโ€™ve gone through this process and the product isnโ€™t right for you, itโ€™s time to find something else. My free How to Pick Gels Cheat Sheet teaches you how gels differ and what to look for based on how your hair feels and your hair goals.

For more problems you can solve on your own, see the rest of my Troubleshooting Series. If youโ€™re still doing a ton of refreshing and restyling, read Why Your Curls Donโ€™t Last Past Wash Day next.

Still Stuck?

If you try this on your own and still arenโ€™t getting results, thatโ€™s what my Group Curl Coaching Program is built for. We do this together.

  • I go through your routine and tell you what I can see needs to be swapped out.
  • I donโ€™t just tell you what to do. I tell you why, so you learn the process and become more self-sufficient with your curls.
  • You learn the testing process and how to recognize these signs until theyโ€™re second nature.

Think of how much money youโ€™ve spent over the years on the wrong products. If you feel confused and want to change your entire routine all the time, itโ€™s because you donโ€™t have a process in place.

Better curls are achievable for everyone with the right process. You just have to determine what your full curl potential is, and thatโ€™s what I help you with.

Early access for my winter program is underway for waitlist members, and doors officially close December 15. I only open enrollment seasonally. Join the waitlist and youโ€™ll get an email with all the details when you can sign up.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


What are you looking for?

Search